How Do I Counsel Students Brokenhearted Over Their Sin?

My wife and I sat across from a weeping sixteen-year-old girl who had slept with her boyfriend, only to be left lonely and brokenhearted. I felt so woefully lost about how to care for this sweet girl. In truth, I was scared to say anything for fear that I would only make her fragile state worse with Christian tropes like “pray more” or “God’s not done with you yet.” 

While these statements may have been true, they simply would not do the job. I knew she needed more from me, and I wanted to give more. I was early in ministry and did not have the tools I needed for this situation. Though I left that church for a new ministry position shortly after that meeting, that interaction never left me. Now that I am in the process of earning a master’s degree in biblical counseling, I often wonder: What if I had known the right words to say?

Through my experience and study in biblical counseling since then, I believe I can provide you with some help that I did not have. By no means am I an expert; however, I truly believe that, by God’s grace, I have received some of the tools I so desperately needed then.

There’s no true one-size-fits-all approach for those brokenhearted over their sin, but there is one source from which all wisdom flows: the inspired Word of God. Therefore, the goal of this article is to give you practical and theological advice regarding how to deal with students—like that sixteen-year-old girl—whose world and heart are in a million pieces.

1. Listen Well

The first and most important practical advice I can give you is simple: listen well. Listening is half the battle when counseling those brokenhearted due to their own sinful mistakes. The minister who listens faithfully begins to understand the situation in which a student finds himself. In doing so, that minister can provide an outside view that gives light and a pathway through the darkness. 

As you listen, the goal is not purely to retain information. Rather, listen with the intent to apply what you know about God and his Word to the situation at hand. There is nothing a person can face to which Scripture does not speak in principle. Your student did not come to you for Freudian-style free thought. She sought her youth minister—hopefully because she knows God is merciful, kind, loving, and righteous.  

The God Who Listens

Scripture shows us numerous times that our Father allows his people to express rage, sadness, confusion, fear, anxiety, and so many more emotions before responding to them. Take, for example, King David after his sinful actions of adultery and murder. In Psalm 51, David cries out to God, heartbroken over his own sin. He proclaims that he is in need of a new heart and expresses such sorrow that you can feel his emotion through the page. 

God does not turn a blind eye or a deaf ear to David. Rather, he inclines his ear to David and listens closely and carefully to him. In the New Testament, Paul confirms David’s title as a man after God’s own heart. Though David committed great and terrible sins, our Father provided him enormous grace and restored him. That doesn’t mean God removed all consequences from David. David still had to grieve his child’s death, as well as unravel the dysfunction he himself had caused. But God was gracious to David even though his sin had earthly consequences. 

If God listens so carefully to his people, shouldn’t youth ministers do the same? Shouldn’t we listen to the cries and anguish of our students if God does? My point is simple: Minister, listen to the brokenhearted, weep with them, and then aim for resolution. Don’t skip the process of listening and understanding just because you have a degree or years of experience. See each person as a unique individual in need of God’s counsel. 

2. Rely on God’s Word

The second important piece of advice I can give is theological: God’s Word is sufficient for the brokenhearted. Famously, Paul writes to Timothy, “All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work” (2 Tim. 3:16-17). This simple text gives you and me all the confidence we need when counseling the brokenhearted. No matter what the person in front of us is facing, God’s Word is sufficient. God knows what his people face due to their sins and provides the guidance they need in his Word.

There are times when it’s necessary to refer a student to outside counseling. In such cases, I’d strongly encourage you to find a good biblical counselor to partner with. However, if we fulfill our biblical mandate to shepherd those who are in our flock and those who come seeking the knowledge and wisdom of the Lord, then we can be assured that God’s Word is fully sufficient to handle the deepest groanings of the human heart.

To shepherd using the Word is a skill that necessitates practice, as do many others. We must know where to go in the Scriptures to find valuable gemstones that care for our students need. Thankfully, the Bible is full of broken and sinful people in need of counseling! 

God Restores Through His Word

The prophets continually express God’s grace towards man’s sinfulness. Through the biblical prophets, God promises both to judge sin and restore those who repent of it. For example, God promises that he will destroy the wickedness of Israel, but also restore them through his promised Messiah in the book of Ezekiel. Israel had run to other gods, committed awful, sinful acts, and forgotten the Lord entirely. Though they would face the devastating consequences of their sin, God would not utterly destroy them. He extended mercy to them. God was faithful to restore Israel, and he is faithful to restore his people today through his Son, Jesus Christ.

Therefore, we must not forget the necessity of God’s Word in counseling, which communicates God’s love for his people. For without it, we are nothing more than a clanging cymbal (1 Cor. 13:1). 

3. Don’t Sugarcoat the Truth. Speak It in Love.

My last practical advice is not to sugarcoat the truth. The truth, in love, is always better than a sugarcoated lie. As youth ministers, we must speak, lead, and teach as Jesus did. At many points, Jesus confronted sinners and interacted with people whose sin had created their precarious situation. In those situations, we can see his truthfulness and his loving-kindness. 

When Jesus interacted with the woman at the well, he did not shy away from the fact that she had had five husbands and was currently living with a man she wasn’t married to. Yet, he lovingly called her away from her sin through grace. 

Oftentimes, when students come to sit in your office, their situations can be attributed to their own impure, sinful, or ignorant decisions—but that does not give us the right to demean or shame them for it. Rather, our hearts should be drawn to compassion for the brokenhearted. We should seek their restoration through God’s Word. Scripture encourages us to speak the truth but to speak it in loving-kindness (Eph. 4:15). We must be truthful with those who sit before us, but also express the beautiful, sin-covering grace the Father bestows upon all believers.

Point Them to Their True Identity in Jesus

So, if that sixteen-year-old girl were in my office today, what would I say to her? Would I confront her with her sinful actions? Or would I console her and seek to restore her sense of self-worth? I hope that by reading this article, my answer is clear: Both. 

I would seek to restore her in the knowledge that God loves her as his child. Jesus came into the world, lived perfectly, and died selflessly to deliver her from her sin and shame. Jesus came to reveal God’s great love for her and the world. Her sin is not her identity, nor is it her finality. I would hope to teach her how to honor the Lord with her life and guide her to seek fulfillment in God and his Word, not in relationships. I would show her love and share with her the grace that has been bestowed upon me so many times and in so many ways. We must counsel the brokenhearted truthfully but also be full of grace, kindness, mercy, and love. 

The Youth Ministry Unscripted Podcast aims to advance gospel-centered youth ministry by equipping and empowering youth ministers and parents to faithfully disciple students toward lifelong faith in Jesus.

Tristan serves as the student pastor at Calvary Baptist Church in Perry, Florida. He is passionate about discipling the next generation and building gospel-centered student ministry in a rural context. Driven by a heart for God's Word and care for students, families, and ministry leaders, he is currently pursuing a Master of Theological Studies through Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. Tristan lives in Perry with his wife, Jessi, and their daughter, Jubilee. Outside of ministry and study, you can usually find him outdoors hunting, playing basketball, or playing the guitar.

More From This Author